Larger protected areas in the tropics and sub-tropics face higher risk of downgrading, downsizing and degazettement

10/19/2015

Assessing influence of economic and demographic changes key for conservation planning 

​Singapore – A team of researchers from the National University of Singapore (NUS), Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS), and Conservation International, found that larger protected areas, especially those in high population density regions, are more likely to undergo a downgrading, downsizing and degazettement (PADDD) event.

Protected areas, like national parks and nature reserves, are areas designated or regulated to achieve specific biodiversity conservation objectives. In parts of the tropics and sub-tropics, protected areas are under pressure from forces related to high human populations and rapid land use change. PADDD is the legal process by which protected areas have their level of protection reduced, are made smaller or are removed completely. 

In the study, a total of 342 PADDD events between 1900 and 2010 across 44 countries in the tropics and sub-tropics were examined. This is the first study to highlight the potential for PADDD to undermine the recommendations from systematic conservation planning.

The findings of the study were published online in leading scientific journal, Global Change Biology, on 19 October 2015. 

Factors influencing the fate of protected areas  
The researchers found a greater probability of PADDD events occurring in larger protected areas, and larger protected areas in more densely populated areas, which is likely due to economic motivations. Larger protected areas have more potentially exploitable land and are more likely to contain valuable geographical features, such as mineral deposits. These size effects are then further exacerbated by local land pressures in regions with high local population densities.

The team also showed PADDD to be a complex and nuanced phenomenon with significant differences in probability of PADDD between countries. Multiple national level influences, such as rule of law, environmental governance, land tenure or policy are potentially influencing PADDD and further national level studies are needed to better understand these mechanics. 

Integrating protected area robustness into future conservation planning
With increasing efforts to assess the efficacy of protected areas worldwide and calls to remove underperforming sites, the findings of this study provides new perspectives to conservation planning processes.

For a start, conservation planners can better consider protected area characteristics, as well as the social, economic and political context in which protected areas are situated, to aid the creation of more efficient and sustainable protected area networks. 

In particular, the dynamics of PADDD events highlight the need for the planning process to explicitly consider the robustness of the protected area towards future economic and demographic changes, as this might influence the fate of individual sites within a protected area network.

Without incorporating PADDD and protected area robustness into systematic conservation planning frameworks when identifying where new sites should be placed, there could be a risk of creating protected area networks with inherent structural vulnerabilities to economic and demographic pressures.

First author of the study, William Symes, a graduate student from the Department of Biological Sciences at the NUS Faculty of Science said, “Protected areas are not static but instead dynamic, shifting institutions that change over time, and it is crucial for conservation planners to recognise this. The global protected area estate is huge and the dynamics driving change within it are poorly understood. We hope that our results will encourage more research on the mechanisms making protected areas become smaller or disappear, leading to more effective conservation in the future.”

"Conserving nature is a long and complicated process and establishing a national park or nature preserve is a first step,” said Dr. Mike Mascia, senior director of social science for Conservation International. “That can be a difficult but important realization for all of us."

“Protected areas are critical for biodiversity conservation and understanding when they work and why is central to conservation planning” said Dr. Madhu Rao, Regional Advisor at the Wildlife Conservation Society. 

The authors of the study are William S. Symes and Assistant Professor L. Roman Carrasco from NUS; Madhu Rao from WCS and NUS, and Michael B. Mascia from Conservational International.

###

For media enquiries, please contact:

GOH Yu Chong
Manager, Media Relations
Office of Corporate Relations
National University of Singapore
Tel: (65) 6601 1653 

Kevin Connor
Senior Media Relations Manager
Conservation International 
Tel: +1 703 341 2405

Stephen Sautner
Executive Director of Communications
WCS
Tel: +1 718 220 3682

About National University of Singapore (NUS)
A leading global university centred in Asia, the National University of Singapore (NUS) is Singapore’s flagship university, which offers a global approach to education and research, with a focus on Asian perspectives and expertise. 
 
NUS has 16 faculties and schools across three campuses. Its transformative education includes a broad-based curriculum underscored by multi-disciplinary courses and cross-faculty enrichment. Over 38,000 students from 100 countries enrich the community with their diverse social and cultural perspectives.
 
NUS has three Research Centres of Excellence (RCE) and 26 university-level research institutes and centres. It is also a partner in Singapore’s fifth RCE. NUS shares a close affiliation with 16 national-level research institutes and centres. Research activities are strategic and robust, and NUS is well-known for its research strengths in engineering, life sciences and biomedicine, social sciences and natural sciences. It also strives to create a supportive and innovative environment to promote creative enterprise within its community.   

This year, NUS celebrates its 110th year of founding together with Singapore’s 50th year of independence. As the island’s first higher education institution established by the local community, NUS prides itself in nurturing generations of leaders and luminaries in Singapore and Asia.
 
For more information on NUS, please visit www.nus.edu.sg. Details on NUS’ 110th Anniversary celebrations are available at nus110.sg.

About Conservation International
Since 1987, Conservation International has been working to improve human well-being through the care of nature. With the guiding principle that nature doesn't need people, but people need nature for food, water, health and livelihoods—CI works with more than 1,000 partners around the world to ensure a healthy, more prosperous planet that supports the well-being of people. Learn more about CI and the "Nature Is Speaking" campaign, and follow CI's work on Facebook, Twitter and YouTube.

About WCS (Wildlife Conservation Society)
WCS saves wildlife and wild places worldwide through science, conservation action, education, and inspiring people to value nature. To achieve our mission, WCS, based at the Bronx Zoo, harnesses the power of its Global Conservation Program in more than 60 nations and in all the world’s oceans and its five wildlife parks in New York City, visited by 4 million people annually. WCS combines its expertise in the field, zoos, and aquarium to achieve its conservation mission. Visit: newsroom.wcs.org​ Follow: @WCSNewsroom. For more information: 347-840-1242.

​​​​​Images Slideshow Carousel (half page)

Carousel Configuration​

EditCarousel Title:Carousel Title value
Edit Carousel Orientation:leftLeft
    EditAnchor tag for sticky nav (optional):[Optional]
    EditImage RenditionID Small:15[Optional]
    EditImage RenditionID Webkit:17[Optional]
    EditImage RenditionID Medium:18[Optional]
    EditImage RenditionID Large:19[Optional]

    Carousel Images

    Image

    EditImage:/SiteCollectionImages/ci_31786304.jpg
    EditImage Alt Text:Image Alt Text value
    EditCaption Title:Caption Title value​
    EditCaption Description:Gorillas in Virunga National Park.
    EditPhoto Credit:© Conservation International/photo by John Martin
    Move UpMove Down​​
    Add another image...
    Remove this module
    ​​​​

    Other Media